Interlaboratory Reproducibility

Scientific meaning

What it measures

Assesses interlaboratory reproducibility using evidence appropriate to reproducibility and replication, distinguishing random uncertainty from systematic error.

Why it matters

Material weakness in interlaboratory reproducibility can change the direction, magnitude, certainty, or biological interpretation of the research conclusion.

Measurement criteria

Independent repeats; between-run/site/analyst variability; concordance of effect direction and magnitude; predefined reproducibility thresholds.

Typical methods of assessment

Structured critical appraisal; quantitative estimation with uncertainty; prespecified thresholds; independent replication; sensitivity and subgroup analyses.

Computation profile

Computation mode

ContextSpecificMetricComputation

Readiness

OperationalDefinitionRequired

Formula status

ContextSpecificProtocolRequired

Method family

metric-specific quantitative or qualitative assessment

Output datatype

xsd:anySimpleType

Unit or scale

Metric-specific continuous, categorical, or ordinal scale

Numeric range

Context dependent

Directionality

ContextDependentDirection

Required inputs

• evidence_records
• assessment_context
• operational_definition
• computation_protocol_version

Optional inputs

• weights
• thresholds
• reference_standard
• expert_adjudication

Machine-readable expression

{
  "language": "BEMO-Expression-JSON",
  "operator": "external_protocol",
  "protocolRef": "REQUIRED"
}

Computation policies

Aggregation

Not specified in source; must be defined and versioned before composite use.

Normalization

None by default; any normalization must be justified, versioned, and validated.

Missing data

Must be declared before computation; report missingness; no silent imputation; perform sensitivity analysis when material.

Uncertainty required

Yes

Uncertainty method

Confidence interval, credible interval, bootstrap distribution, inter-rater reliability, or sensitivity analysis as scientifically applicable.

Confidence interval required

Yes

Threshold policy

Prespecify, justify, version, and sensitivity-test thresholds; do not derive and evaluate on the same data without correction.

Decision thresholds

No universal threshold declared

Quality control

Source provenance; input validation; duplicate control; uncertainty reporting; independent or orthogonal validation where applicable.

Calibration

As applicable; mandatory for probabilistic or normalized outputs.

Applicability and validation

Evidence object

Result / experiment / study / body of evidence, as applicable

Evidence level

Result / experiment / study / body of evidence, as applicable

Study types

All experimental, computational, clinical, and omics studies

Domain

Reproducibility and Replication

Required data sources

Context-specific; use source references, registered studies, primary data, and authoritative biomedical resources as applicable.

Validation status

Source maturity: Established; BEMO computation profile requires independent validation.

Benchmark

A representative, versioned benchmark set is required before production use.

Reference standard

Use an independent reference standard when one exists; document expert-adjudicated alternatives.

External validation required

Yes

Interpretation safeguards

Common misinterpretations

Treating interlaboratory reproducibility as interchangeable with overall study quality, or interpreting a favorable value as proof that all other bias and validity domains are satisfactory.

Limitations

Depends on context, operational definition, thresholds, data quality, and evaluator judgment; it should not be used as a stand-alone summary score without domain-level evidence.

Dependency status

Not yet curated. Closely related metrics are represented; causal or computational dependencies require expert curation.

Source provenance

Source workbook

Pure_Biomedical_Evidence_Research_Metrics_Part_2(3).xlsx

Source worksheet

Biomedical Evidence Metrics

Source row

403

Source record SHA-256

0977ae8d7278730723c8d024585a95d1125aa9fe6da897fe977a079b172ddb48

Definition source

Pure_Biomedical_Evidence_Research_Metrics_Part_2(3).xlsx row 403; see source_references

Ontology IRI

https://w3id.org/bemo/BEMO_2000396

Profile IRI

https://w3id.org/bemo/profile/BEMO_2000396

SHACL shape

https://w3id.org/bemo/shapes/BEMO_2000396_AssessmentShape

Scientific references (6)

1. https://www.prisma-statement.org/prisma-2020-checklistSource framework, standard, guideline, or originSource-preserved; URL reachability not asserted by this package
2. https://www.consort-spirit.org/Source framework, standard, guideline, or originSource-preserved; URL reachability not asserted by this package
3. https://www.fged.org/projects/miameSource framework, standard, guideline, or originSource-preserved; URL reachability not asserted by this package
4. https://www.fged.org/projects/minseqe/Source framework, standard, guideline, or originSource-preserved; URL reachability not asserted by this package
5. https://www.psidev.info/miapeSource framework, standard, guideline, or originSource-preserved; URL reachability not asserted by this package
6. https://arriveguidelines.org/arrive-guidelinesSource framework, standard, guideline, or originSource-preserved; URL reachability not asserted by this package

Governance and FAIR status

Lifecycle

Candidate

Approval

Draft

Owner

BEMO Project

Curator

Unassigned

Reviewer

Unassigned

License

Pending owner approval; CC BY 4.0 recommended for OBO compatibility.

Findable

Provisional: stable local ID assigned; public namespace registration pending.

Accessible

Provisional: package is distributable; permanent public release location pending.

Interoperable

Yes: OWL 2, RDF, SKOS, SHACL, JSON-LD, CSV, and OBO-style identifiers.

Reusable

Provisional: rich metadata supplied; open-license owner approval pending.

Governance note

Candidate term pending scientific, ontology-engineering, and computation-method review.

Editor note

Source content preserved verbatim; computation metadata is a generated default and must be curated before normative use.