{"metric_id":"BEMO:2000228","metric_iri":"https://w3id.org/bemo/BEMO_2000228","preferred_label":"Phenocopy Risk","normalized_label":"phenocopy_risk","abbreviation":"","pillar_id":"BEMO:1000007","pillar_label":"Genetics, Omics, and Systems Biology","category_id":"BEMO:1100009","category_label":"Genetics and Variant Evidence","parent_class_iri":"https://w3id.org/bemo/BEMO_1100009","ontology_namespace":"BEMO","ontology_version":"0.1.0","metric_version":"1.0.0","lifecycle_status":"Candidate","deprecated":false,"replacement_id":"","created_date":"2026-08-02","modified_date":"2026-08-02","language":"en","license_status":"Pending owner approval; CC BY 4.0 recommended for OBO compatibility.","scientific_definition":"The probability or degree that phenocopy introduces systematic distortion into a biomedical estimate or conclusion.","what_it_measures":"Assesses phenocopy risk using evidence appropriate to genetics and variant evidence, distinguishing random uncertainty from systematic error.","why_it_matters":"Material weakness in phenocopy risk can change the direction, magnitude, certainty, or biological interpretation of the research conclusion.","measurement_criteria":"Prespecified signaling questions; direction and likely magnitude of distortion; domain-level and overall judgment; sensitivity to plausible bias.","methods_of_assessment":"Structured critical appraisal; quantitative estimation with uncertainty; prespecified thresholds; independent replication; sensitivity and subgroup analyses.","units_or_scale_source":"Ordinal risk rating or quantitative percentage/probability; lower is generally better","evidence_level_source":"Result / experiment / study / body of evidence, as applicable","applicable_study_types_source":"Mendelian disease, cancer genetics, association, segregation, and functional studies","related_frameworks_source":"ClinGen; ACMG AMP; STREGA; Gene Ontology","closely_related_metrics_source":"Founder-Effect Assessment; Locus Heterogeneity Assessment; Genotype–Phenotype Concordance","common_misinterpretations":"Treating phenocopy risk as interchangeable with overall study quality, or interpreting a favorable value as proof that all other bias and validity domains are satisfactory.","limitations":"Depends on context, operational definition, thresholds, data quality, and evaluator judgment; it should not be used as a stand-alone summary score without domain-level evidence.","scientific_importance":8,"frequency_of_use":"Established within specialty","maturity_of_metric":"Established","references_source":"https://clinicalgenome.org/curation-activities/gene-disease-validity/ | https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25741868/ | https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/strega/ | https://geneontology.org/docs/guide-go-evidence-codes/","metric_kind":"AtomicOrCompositeNotYetCurated","output_concept":"BEMO:0000200 Metric Assessment","scale_type":"RiskScale","output_datatype":"xsd:string_or_decimal","unit_ontology_iri":"","unit_text":"Ordinal risk rating or quantitative percentage/probability; lower is generally better","minimum_value":null,"maximum_value":null,"null_value":null,"directionality":"LowerIsBetter","computation_mode":"RiskAssessmentComputation","computation_readiness":"RubricOrModelRequired","formula_status":"ContextSpecificProtocolRequired","human_readable_formula":"Apply a versioned risk rubric or calibrated probability model defined for the metric and context.","machine_formula_language":"BEMO-Expression-JSON","machine_formula_expression":"{\"language\":\"BEMO-Expression-JSON\",\"operator\":\"external_protocol\",\"protocolRef\":\"REQUIRED\",\"allowed_outputs\":[\"ordinal_risk_category\",\"probability\",\"percentage\"]}","required_inputs":"risk_factors; assessment_context; rubric_or_model_version; evidence_records","optional_inputs":"weights; thresholds; calibration_dataset","aggregation_rule":"Not specified in source; must be defined and versioned before composite use.","normalization_method":"None by default; any normalization must be justified, versioned, and validated.","missing_data_policy":"Must be declared before computation; report missingness; no silent imputation; perform sensitivity analysis when material.","uncertainty_required":true,"uncertainty_method":"Confidence interval, credible interval, bootstrap distribution, inter-rater reliability, or sensitivity analysis as scientifically applicable.","confidence_interval_required":true,"threshold_policy":"Prespecify, justify, version, and sensitivity-test thresholds; do not derive and evaluate on the same data without correction.","decision_thresholds":"","quality_control_requirements":"Source provenance; input validation; duplicate control; uncertainty reporting; independent or orthogonal validation where applicable.","calibration_requirement":"Required for probability outputs; rubric reliability required for ordinal outputs.","validation_status":"Source maturity: Established; BEMO computation profile requires independent validation.","benchmark_requirement":"A representative, versioned benchmark set is required before production use.","gold_standard_requirement":"Use an independent reference standard when one exists; document expert-adjudicated alternatives.","external_validation_required":true,"evidence_object_scope":"Result / experiment / study / body of evidence, as applicable","study_type_applicability":"Mendelian disease, cancer genetics, association, segregation, and functional studies","domain_applicability":"Genetics and Variant Evidence","required_data_sources":"Context-specific; use source references, registered studies, primary data, and authoritative biomedical resources as applicable.","computational_method_family":"risk assessment or calibrated probability estimation","software_implementation_status":"Specification generated; metric-specific reference implementation pending.","reference_implementation":"scripts/compute_metric.py --metric BEMO:2000228","api_endpoint_template":"/v1/metrics/BEMO:2000228/compute","json_schema_ref":"schemas/bemo-assessment.schema.json","shacl_shape_iri":"https://w3id.org/bemo/shapes/BEMO_2000228_AssessmentShape","provenance_model":"W3C PROV-O","source_workbook":"Pure_Biomedical_Evidence_Research_Metrics_Part_2(3).xlsx","source_sheet":"Biomedical Evidence Metrics","source_row":235,"source_record_hash":"eba377fe2c190b6390cd804f64874ad58540debe287184cfa259e70d97d1fcc8","source_references":"https://clinicalgenome.org/curation-activities/gene-disease-validity/ | https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25741868/ | https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/strega/ | https://geneontology.org/docs/guide-go-evidence-codes/","curator":"Unassigned","reviewer":"Unassigned","owner":"BEMO Project","approval_status":"Draft","governance_note":"Candidate term pending scientific, ontology-engineering, and computation-method review.","editor_note":"Source content preserved verbatim; computation metadata is a generated default and must be curated before normative use.","definition_source":"Pure_Biomedical_Evidence_Research_Metrics_Part_2(3).xlsx row 235; see source_references","exact_synonyms":"","broad_synonyms":"","narrow_synonyms":"","related_synonyms":"","xrefs":"https://clinicalgenome.org/curation-activities/gene-disease-validity/ | https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25741868/ | https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/strega/ | https://geneontology.org/docs/guide-go-evidence-codes/","obo_subset":"bemo_genetics_omics_and_systems_biology","fair_findable":"Provisional: stable local ID assigned; public namespace registration pending.","fair_accessible":"Provisional: package is distributable; permanent public release location pending.","fair_interoperable":"Yes: OWL 2, RDF, SKOS, SHACL, JSON-LD, CSV, and OBO-style identifiers.","fair_reusable":"Provisional: rich metadata supplied; open-license owner approval pending.","confidence_in_metric_definition":"Not yet formally assessed","metric_dependency_status":"Not yet curated","dependency_notes":"Closely related metrics are represented; causal or computational dependencies require expert curation.","implementation_notes":"Exact execution requires a validated computation profile unless formula_status is GenericTemplateDefined.","test_case_status":"Generic validation template provided","example_input_ref":"examples/example_metric_input.json","example_output_ref":"examples/example_metric_output.jsonld","notes":"No source scientific statement was silently altered or replaced.","url_id":"BEMO-2000228","required_inputs_list":["risk_factors","assessment_context","rubric_or_model_version","evidence_records"],"optional_inputs_list":["weights","thresholds","calibration_dataset"],"source_record":{"source_workbook":"Pure_Biomedical_Evidence_Research_Metrics_Part_2(3).xlsx","source_sheet":"Biomedical Evidence Metrics","source_row":"235","Category":"Genetics and Variant Evidence","Metric":"Phenocopy Risk","Scientific Definition":"The probability or degree that phenocopy introduces systematic distortion into a biomedical estimate or conclusion.","What It Measures":"Assesses phenocopy risk using evidence appropriate to genetics and variant evidence, distinguishing random uncertainty from systematic error.","Why It Matters":"Material weakness in phenocopy risk can change the direction, magnitude, certainty, or biological interpretation of the research conclusion.","Measurement Criteria":"Prespecified signaling questions; direction and likely magnitude of distortion; domain-level and overall judgment; sensitivity to plausible bias.","Typical Methods of Assessment":"Structured critical appraisal; quantitative estimation with uncertainty; prespecified thresholds; independent replication; sensitivity and subgroup analyses.","Units or Scale (if applicable)":"Ordinal risk rating or quantitative percentage/probability; lower is generally better","Evidence Level Where Used":"Result / experiment / study / body of evidence, as applicable","Applicable Study Types":"Mendelian disease, cancer genetics, association, segregation, and functional studies","Related Frameworks":"ClinGen; ACMG AMP; STREGA; Gene Ontology","Closely Related Metrics":"Founder-Effect Assessment; Locus Heterogeneity Assessment; Genotype–Phenotype Concordance","Common Misinterpretations":"Treating phenocopy risk as interchangeable with overall study quality, or interpreting a favorable value as proof that all other bias and validity domains are satisfactory.","Limitations":"Depends on context, operational definition, thresholds, data quality, and evaluator judgment; it should not be used as a stand-alone summary score without domain-level evidence.","Scientific Importance (1–10)":"8","Frequency of Use":"Established within specialty","Maturity of Metric":"Established","References or Origin":"https://clinicalgenome.org/curation-activities/gene-disease-validity/ | https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25741868/ | https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/strega/ | https://geneontology.org/docs/guide-go-evidence-codes/"},"computation_profile":{"metric_id":"BEMO:2000228","preferred_label":"Phenocopy Risk","computation_mode":"RiskAssessmentComputation","computation_readiness":"RubricOrModelRequired","formula_status":"ContextSpecificProtocolRequired","human_readable_formula":"Apply a versioned risk rubric or calibrated probability model defined for the metric and context.","machine_formula_language":"BEMO-Expression-JSON","machine_formula_expression":{"language":"BEMO-Expression-JSON","operator":"external_protocol","protocolRef":"REQUIRED","allowed_outputs":["ordinal_risk_category","probability","percentage"]},"required_inputs":"risk_factors; assessment_context; rubric_or_model_version; evidence_records","optional_inputs":"weights; thresholds; calibration_dataset","output_concept":"BEMO:0000200 Metric Assessment","output_datatype":"xsd:string_or_decimal","scale_type":"RiskScale","unit_ontology_iri":"","unit_text":"Ordinal risk rating or quantitative percentage/probability; lower is generally better","minimum_value":null,"maximum_value":null,"null_value":null,"directionality":"LowerIsBetter","aggregation_rule":"Not specified in source; must be defined and versioned before composite use.","normalization_method":"None by default; any normalization must be justified, versioned, and validated.","missing_data_policy":"Must be declared before computation; report missingness; no silent imputation; perform sensitivity analysis when material.","uncertainty_required":true,"uncertainty_method":"Confidence interval, credible interval, bootstrap distribution, inter-rater reliability, or sensitivity analysis as scientifically applicable.","confidence_interval_required":true,"threshold_policy":"Prespecify, justify, version, and sensitivity-test thresholds; do not derive and evaluate on the same data without correction.","decision_thresholds":"","quality_control_requirements":"Source provenance; input validation; duplicate control; uncertainty reporting; independent or orthogonal validation where applicable.","calibration_requirement":"Required for probability outputs; rubric reliability required for ordinal outputs.","validation_status":"Source maturity: Established; BEMO computation profile requires independent validation.","benchmark_requirement":"A representative, versioned benchmark set is required before production use.","gold_standard_requirement":"Use an independent reference standard when one exists; document expert-adjudicated alternatives.","external_validation_required":true,"computational_method_family":"risk assessment or calibrated probability estimation","software_implementation_status":"Specification generated; metric-specific reference implementation pending.","reference_implementation":"scripts/compute_metric.py --metric BEMO:2000228","api_endpoint_template":"/v1/metrics/BEMO:2000228/compute","json_schema_ref":"schemas/bemo-assessment.schema.json","shacl_shape_iri":"https://w3id.org/bemo/shapes/BEMO_2000228_AssessmentShape","profile_version":"0.1.0","profile_iri":"https://w3id.org/bemo/profile/BEMO_2000228"},"relationships":[{"predicate":"closely_related_metric","source":"Source workbook: Closely Related Metrics","status":"SourceDeclared","directionality":"Directed as recorded; may be symmetric in the source","version":"0.1.0","metric_id":"BEMO:2000219","preferred_label":"Founder-Effect Assessment"},{"predicate":"closely_related_metric","source":"Source workbook: Closely Related Metrics","status":"SourceDeclared","directionality":"Directed as recorded; may be symmetric in the source","version":"0.1.0","metric_id":"BEMO:2000224","preferred_label":"Locus Heterogeneity Assessment"},{"predicate":"closely_related_metric","source":"Source workbook: Closely Related Metrics","status":"SourceDeclared","directionality":"Directed as recorded; may be symmetric in the source","version":"0.1.0","metric_id":"BEMO:2000222","preferred_label":"Genotype–Phenotype Concordance"}],"incoming_relationships":[{"predicate":"closely_related_metric","source":"Source workbook: Closely Related Metrics","status":"SourceDeclared","directionality":"Directed as recorded; may be symmetric in the source","version":"0.1.0","metric_id":"BEMO:2000218","preferred_label":"Expressivity Consistency"},{"predicate":"closely_related_metric","source":"Source workbook: Closely Related Metrics","status":"SourceDeclared","directionality":"Directed as recorded; may be symmetric in the source","version":"0.1.0","metric_id":"BEMO:2000219","preferred_label":"Founder-Effect Assessment"},{"predicate":"closely_related_metric","source":"Source workbook: Closely Related Metrics","status":"SourceDeclared","directionality":"Directed as recorded; may be symmetric in the source","version":"0.1.0","metric_id":"BEMO:2000224","preferred_label":"Locus Heterogeneity Assessment"}],"references":[{"order":1,"url":"https://clinicalgenome.org/curation-activities/gene-disease-validity/","type":"Source framework, standard, guideline, or origin","verification_status":"Source-preserved; URL reachability not asserted by this package"},{"order":2,"url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25741868/","type":"Source framework, standard, guideline, or origin","verification_status":"Source-preserved; URL reachability not asserted by this package"},{"order":3,"url":"https://www.equator-network.org/reporting-guidelines/strega/","type":"Source framework, standard, guideline, or origin","verification_status":"Source-preserved; URL reachability not asserted by this package"},{"order":4,"url":"https://geneontology.org/docs/guide-go-evidence-codes/","type":"Source framework, standard, guideline, or origin","verification_status":"Source-preserved; URL reachability not asserted by this package"}]}